Phones answered 24/7Kettering, OH
Call (833) 490-5225
(833) 490-5225
Guide

After a tornado: roof damage and the water that follows

What the May 2019 Dayton-area tornadoes showed about roof damage and water entry, how to cover an open roof, and what to photograph for an insurer.

Illustration for the guide "After a tornado: roof damage and the water that follows" (Kettering, OH)
Short answer

A tornado can tear shingles, lift flashing and open a roof to rain before the storm is over. The May 27, 2019 outbreak damaged homes in Trotwood, Riverside and Beavercreek, and the water that followed is a job of its own. Cover the opening, document it, then arrange repairs in that order.

Key takeaways

  • The May 27, 2019 outbreak included an EF4 tornado in the Dayton area and a separate EF3 tornado in Beavercreek.
  • Wind can open a roof, and rain that enters through the opening can soak ceilings, insulation and walls for days.
  • Cover an opening as soon as it is safe to reach it, with a tarp fastened to sound structure rather than loose shingles.
  • Photograph the damage from the ground and from inside before any tarp or crew moves anything.
  • Roof repair and interior water cleanup are separate jobs, and the scope should say which work belongs to which.
  • Stay off a damaged roof and out of the attic until a qualified person has checked the structure.

What did the May 2019 tornadoes do in the Dayton area?

The May 27, 2019 outbreak produced an EF4 tornado that struck the Dayton area, with its worst damage in Trotwood and near Riverside Drive and the Stillwater River. A separate EF3 hit Beavercreek. Counts of damaged homes differ by source, so this guide describes the damage without printing a total.

The tornado outbreak of May 27, 2019 included an EF4 tornado that formed in the late evening and dissipated about half an hour later, with an estimated peak wind near 170 miles per hour. Its worst damage was in Trotwood and near Riverside Drive and the Stillwater River, and it had weakened to an EF1 by the time it entered Riverside.

A separate EF3 tornado struck Beavercreek the same night, and the storms damaged homes in Huber Heights as well. Counts of destroyed and damaged homes vary by source and have been revised over time, so this guide does not print a total that could be wrong.

For a homeowner the lesson is the sequence the storm forces. Wind opens the roof, rain follows, and the first decisions concern the opening rather than the room below it. Understanding that order is the difference between a dry house in a month and a ceiling that falls in the second week.

Newcomers to the Dayton area often expect a tornado to leave only a missing roof. In practice the opening is the start of the problem, and the house can take on water for days after the wind has stopped. That is why the first steps concern the opening rather than the look of the roof.

How does wind turn a roof into a water route?

Wind lifts shingles, tears flashing away from the wall and displaces ridge caps. Each gap gives rain a path to the decking, the insulation and the ceiling below, and water can travel along framing before it shows.

Shingles are held by nails and sealant, and a strong gust can pull a row loose and leave the underlayment exposed. Once the underlayment is open, water runs down the slope and finds the nearest seam in the decking. The first visible sign may be a stain on a ceiling several feet from the actual opening.

Flashing around chimneys, vents and valleys is the next weak point. Metal bent by wind can let water in along a line rather than at a single hole, which makes the leak harder to find. A homeowner who looks only for a missing shingle may miss the real route entirely.

Water also travels inside the attic and the wall cavity. Insulation holds moisture against the framing, and a wet ceiling can stay damp long after the surface looks dry. The readings taken inside the house are what show how far the water actually traveled.

Trees and branches can make the damage harder to read. A limb that fell across the roof may hide a crease in the decking or a torn vent, and the first walkthrough is the moment to ask what is under it before anything is moved.

What should you cover first, and how?

Cover the opening before anything else, using a secured tarp, and only when it is safe to get on the roof. A loose tarp in wind can cause more harm than the original opening.

Safety comes first. Do not climb a damaged roof, and do not work near power lines that may have come down with the storm. If a roof is steep, wet or unstable, keep off it and call for help. A tarp that is not secured will lift and tear in the next gust.

Once the area is safe, cover the opening with a tarp that extends well past the damage and is fastened to sound structure, not only to shingles that may come loose. Weigh the edges with boards or sandbags. A covered opening buys time for the crew, but it does not repair the roof.

Take the photographs before the cover goes on, if you can. Shoot the roof from the ground, the opening from inside the attic and the stains on each ceiling. Those images are the record of what the storm did, and they help an insurer see the sequence of events.

What does the interior need once water gets in?

The interior needs an assessment of every wet material, removal of anything that cannot be dried and drying to measured readings. Ceilings that have sagged or stained are the first to come down, so they should be checked before anyone stands below them.

Ceilings with water above them are heavy and can fall without warning. Keep people out of rooms with sagging drywall, and remove or support any fixture hanging from a wet ceiling. A crew will usually cut a small inspection hole to see the cavity, which lets the team read the moisture and decide what needs to come out.

Insulation that has soaked up water loses its value and usually comes out. Carpet and pad that are wet from a ceiling leak may be removed, and wood trim that has swelled may be dried or replaced depending on its condition. The scope should name each of these decisions rather than leaving them to the crew on the day.

Drying follows readings, not a set number of days. Equipment stays until the wood, drywall and framing reach their target readings, and the crew logs each reading so the trend is visible. A room that looks dry at the surface may still hold moisture inside the wall, which is why the logs matter as much as the appearance of the room.

Check the exterior walls below the roof edge as well. Water that runs down an outside wall can wet the top plate and the wall cavity without showing indoors until much later. A crew with moisture meters will check those points, and a homeowner can photograph any stain line on the siding to help.

How should roof repair and water cleanup be separated?

Roof repair and interior water cleanup are separate jobs, so the scope should say which work belongs to which trade. Mixing them up leads to confusion about who is responsible for what, and about when the house is actually watertight.

The roof work makes the building watertight: decking, underlayment, shingles, flashing and vents. The restoration work handles the water that got inside: extraction, removal, drying and cleaning. Each needs its own scope and its own record, and the two should be coordinated so that drying does not begin in a room that is still taking rain.

Ask the roofer and the restoration crew to agree on the order of work. Drying cannot succeed while rain is still entering, and a roof repair completed before the interior is opened can seal moisture inside the wall. A short meeting or a shared note usually settles the sequence.

Keep the two sets of paperwork together. The roof estimate, the drying scope, the photographs and the insurer's letters belong in one folder, dated, so each part of the claim can be read against the same timeline.

Keep a list of who was in the house the night of the storm and what each person noticed. A dated list written in the same week is useful when an insurer asks when the water was first seen.

What should a homeowner do in the first week?

In the first week, stay safe, cover the opening, photograph everything, report the loss and arrange an assessment. Most of the expensive mistakes come from waiting for the damage to look worse before acting.

The first day is about safety and the opening. Check the power, keep out of wet rooms and cover the roof as soon as it is safe to do so. Note the time and the weather, because insurers ask when the damage was discovered and when it was secured.

The next few days are about records and the insurer. Report the loss, ask what the policy requires and keep the claim number in one place. Ask whether the insurer wants to inspect before any repairs are made, and follow the answer you receive in writing.

Then call for a walkthrough. Call (833) 490-5225 to describe the storm damage, and someone picks up and takes the details, then gives the safety steps. The crew assesses the roof openings and the interior water and writes a scope the homeowner can compare line by line with any roof estimate.

Plan for the second wave of work. Once the roof is closed and the room is dry, the finish work, the paint, the trim and the flooring is a separate scope again. Ask the restoration crew which materials are left and which need replacing, so the finish estimate starts from the right baseline.

Frequently asked questions

Should I climb onto the roof to tarp it myself?

Only if the roof is low, dry and stable, you have a secure way to stand and no lines are nearby. Otherwise call for help. A fall during storm cleanup is a far more serious problem than a leak.

Will the insurer handle the roof and the water damage separately?

It depends on the policy and the cause. Ask the insurer how each part is handled, and keep the scope for each one separate, so the claim is not confused by a single combined total.

Why is there a stain on my ceiling far from the damage?

Water travels along framing and insulation before it shows. The stain marks where water surfaced, not necessarily where it entered. A crew can read the moisture to trace the route.

How long does drying take after a roof leak?

It depends on the materials and how long they were wet. Drying ends when the readings reach target, and the number of visits follows from that. No single number of days is promised here.

This guide is general information for Montgomery County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Still stuck? We pick up 24/7.

If it's an emergency, call now. For non-urgent help, send the form and we'll call you back.

Keep reading

More guides

What to check when the Great Miami is running high

When the Great Miami is high, the valley's dams and floodgates may be working, parks and roads may close, and the house has to be checked from the outside before water reaches the basement.

WhatsApp